Bulgaria's crisis: Poverty protests
Desperate demonstrations against an ephemeral government
SIX people have set themselves on fire in Bulgaria in less than a month. Three have died. The death by self-immolation of Plamen Goranov, a 36-year-old amateur photographer and rock climber, especially shocked the public. Mr Goranov has become Bulgaria's Jan Palach (the student who set himself on fire in 1969 to protest against the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia), a symbol of the protests that have rocked the country in recent weeks. "You fired up our courage and love for freedom", said one banner at the national day of mourning following his death.
Self-immolation is not a new phenomenon in Bulgaria. According to Médecins Sans Frontières, a medical charity, Bulgaria, a country of 7.3m people, had an average of 7.4 self-immolations a year between 1983 and 2002, most of them politically motivated. Yet this wave of protests--and individuals' willingness to make the ultimate sacrifice for political goals--is worse than any previous one since the collapse of communism. Bulgarians have been worn down by rampant corruption, mismanagement in both the public and the private sector, useless bureaucracy, high unemployment and poverty. "The deep-seated cause for the political crisis is poverty," says Kristofor Pavlov, chief economist at UniCredit Bulbank in Sofia.
The protests have already brought down the government of Boyko Borisov, who resigned last month, ostensibly because, in his own words, he "won't participate in a government under which the police are beating people". In early March Rosen Plevneliev, the president, announced a caretaker cabinet led by Marin Raykov, a former ambassador to France (who will also double as foreign minister). On the day the president announced the interim government a couple of hundred protesters threw toilet rolls at the parliament building and carried brooms and signs saying "Let's sweep out the trash".
The new government of mostly competent technocrats cannot do much before the general election on May 12th. "We will try, with the limited resources and little time at our disposal, to help the most vulnerable parts of the population," says Deyana Kostadinova, deputy prime minister and labour minister. Unemployment went above 12% in February, its highest since 2005. More than 22% of the population live below the official poverty line. The average monthly wage is EUR400 ($517).
The question is who will win the election in May--and whether the winners will be able to restore calm, stick to Bulgaria's policy of fiscal austerity and finally clean the Augean stables of corporate Bulgaria. This would help the country to secure much-needed European Union (EU) funds. Until now it has been a laggard in absorption of EU money.
In the first opinion polls since his government's resignation, Mr Borisov's centre-right Citizens for European Development of Bulgaria (GERB) held a slight lead over the Socialist opposition. According to Gallup, support for GERB was at 19.7%, down from 22% in February; support for the Socialist Party fell to 18.6% from 22%. Mr Borisov's resignation (widely seen as a tactical move to preserve the political capital that GERB had left) seems to have paid off. More worrying is the rise of the far-right nationalist Attack party: its support jumped to 5% from 1.2% in February. Attack will be the election's wild card: none of the main parties wants to form a coalition with the extremist group.
March 23, 2013
Political outlook: Political forces at a glance
Government: Bulgaria is a parliamentary democracy. Parliament consists of the single-chamber, 240-seat National Assembly. Since the election in July 2009, the centre-right Citizens for European Development of Bulgaria (CEDB) has governed alone, despite lacking a parliamentary majority (it won 117 seats in parliament). The government is headed by the prime minister, Boiko Borisov, who is also the leader of the CEDB. The president is Rosen Plevneliev, a former minister of regional development in the CEDB government, who was elected in October 2011.
| Parliamentary forces after the election on Jul 5th 2009 | ||
| % of vote | No. of seats | |
| Citizens for European Development of Bulgaria | 39.7 | 117 |
| Coalition for Bulgaria (Bulgarian Socialist Party & partners) | 17.7 | 40 |
| Movement for Rights & Freedoms | 14.5 | 37 |
| Ataka | 9.4 | 21 |
| The Blue Coalition (Union of Democratic Forces & Democrats for a Strong Bulgaria) | 6.8 | 15 |
| Law, Justice & Order
Party | 4.1 | 10 |
| Total incl others | 100.0 | 240 |
| Source: Central Election Commission. | ||
Download the numbers in Excel
Next elections: According to the constitution, the parliament has a four-year term following an election and the president has a five-year term of office. The next parliamentary election is to be held in mid-2013. The next presidential election will be held in October 2016.
Download text file (csv format)
June 01, 2012
Official name
Republic of Bulgaria
Legal system
Based on the constitution of July 1991
National legislature
Unicameral National Assembly of 240 members, elected by proportional representation. Following the election in July 2009, Citizens for European Development of Bulgaria is the largest parliamentary party
Electoral system
Universal direct suffrage from the age of 18
National elections
October 2011 (presidential) and July 4th 2009 (parliamentary). Next presidential election due in October 2016; pre-term parliamentary election May 12th 2013
Head of state
Rosen Plevneliev, elected president in October 2011
National government
Caretaker government
Main political parties and groupings
Bulgarian Socialist Party (BSP; previously the Bulgarian Communist Party); National Movement for Stability and Progress (NMSP; formerly the Simeon II National Movement, centred on the former king Simeon Saxe-Coburg); Movement for Rights and Freedoms (MRF; formed mainly from the ethnic Turkish minority); Bulgarian New Democracy (BND; formed by rebel NMSP deputies in December 2007), Blue Coalition (comprising the Union of Democratic Forces/UDF and Democrats for a Strong Bulgaria/DSB, a party made up of former members of the UDF); Bulgarian People's Union (BPU; a centre-right grouping, most of whose members were previously in the UDF); Ataka (Attack; a nationalist grouping that emerged just before the parliamentary election in June 2005); Citizens for European Development of Bulgaria (CEDB; led by Boiko Borisov, a former mayor of the capital, Sofia); Napred is a coalition of three parties: the Internal Macedonian Revolutionary Organisation-Bulgarian National Movement (VMRO-BND), the Liberal Initiative for Democratic European Development (LIDER) and the Agricultural National Alliance (ZNS); Law, Justice and Order Party (LJO)
Council of ministers
Prime minister: Marin Raykov
Deputy prime minister & labour minister: Deyana Kostadinova
Deputy prime minister & EU funds minister: Iliyana Tsanova
Deputy prime minister & regional development minister: Ekaterina Zaharieva
Key ministers
Agriculture & food: Ivan Stankov
Culture: Vladimir Penev
Defence: Todor Tagarev
Economy, energy & tourism: Assen Vassilev
Education, youth & science: Nikolay Miloshev
E-government: Roman Vasilev
Environment & water: Yulian Popov
Finance: Kalin Hristov
Foreign: Marin Raykoc
Health: Nikolay Petrov
Interior: Petya Parvanova
Justice: Dragomir Yordanov
Sport: Petar Stoychev
Transport, communication & IT: Christian Krastev
Central bank governor
Ivan Iskrov
March 28, 2013
Outlook for 2013-17
Review
March 28, 2013
Fact sheet
| Annual data | 2012 | Historical averages (%) | 2008-12 |
| Population (m) | 7.3 | Population growth | -0.7 |
| GDP (US$ bn; market exchange rate) | 51.0 | Real GDP growth | 0.6 |
| GDP (US$ bn; purchasing power parity) | 97.8 | Real domestic demand growth | -1.6 |
| GDP per head (US$; market exchange rate) | 6,976 | Inflation | 4.9 |
| GDP per head (US$; purchasing power parity) | 13,390 | Current-account balance (% of GDP) | -6.6 |
| Exchange rate (av) :US$ | 1.52 | FDI inflows (% of GDP) | 7.3 |
Download the numbers in Excel
Background: After a violent communist takeover, Bulgaria became a People's Republic in 1947. The communist regime collapsed in November 1989, but the Bulgarian Communist Party-renamed the Bulgarian Socialist Party (BSP)-won the country's first free election. The anti-communist Union of Democratic Forces (UDF) formed a government after the election in October 1991, but was replaced in December 1992 by a technocratic government backed by the BSP and the mainly ethnic Turkish Movement for Rights and Freedoms (MRF). The election in December 1994 returned the BSP to power, but a severe economic crisis in 1996-97 forced an early election in April 1997, which a UDF-led centre-right coalition won. The Simeon II National Movement (SNM, which has since changed its name to the National Movement for Stability and Progress/NMSP) won the election in 2001 and governed with the MRF until the election in June 2005. The BSP won the election in 2005 and governed with the NMSP and the MRF until the election in July 2009, after which the centre-right Citizens for European Development of Bulgaria (CEDB) formed a minority government. The CEDB government resigned on February 20th 2013 following mass protests, giving way to a caretaker government pending elections on May 12th.
Political structure: Bulgaria has a unicameral legislature. The 240-member National Assembly is constitutionally the highest state authority. Its members are elected by proportional representation. A new constitution was passed in July 1991. The head of state is a directly elected non-executive president, who has the power to delay legislation, but not to block it.
Policy issues: Following the economic crash in 1996-97, an IMF-backed currency board was introduced. The currency board is intended to remain in place until Bulgaria adopts the euro (which is unlikely before 2015). The currency board limits monetary policy, and so fiscal policy will remain crucial for macroeconomic stability. Further reform of the judiciary, and intensified efforts to combat corruption and organised crime, will be needed if Bulgaria is to avoid any further imposition of punitive restrictions on its use of EU funding.
Taxation: There is a flat-tax system in place, with a single, 10% rate applied on personal income since January 2008, and a 10% rate applied on company profits since January 2007. Value-added tax (VAT) is levied at a single rate of 20%, although tourism packages sold abroad carry a rate of 9%.
Foreign trade: In 2011 exports of goods (fob) amounted to US$28.1bn and imports of goods (fob) amounted to US$30.9bn. The current-account surplus was around US$500m (0.9% of GDP), having swung from a deficit of 1.2% of GDP in 2010.
| Major exports 2011 | % of total | Major imports 2011 | % of total |
| Other metals | 12.4 | Crude oil & natural gas | 17.1 |
| Clothing & footwear | 7.5 | Machinery & equipment | 7.0 |
| Iron & steel | 4.4 | Chemicals, plastics & rubber | 7.0 |
| Chemicals, plastics & rubber | 4.1 | Textiles | 4.8 |
| Leading markets 2011 | % of total | Leading suppliers 2011 | % of total |
| Germany | 11.9 | Russia | 18.3 |
| Romania | 9.6 | Germany | 11.2 |
| Italy | 8.3 | Italy | 7.4 |
| Turkey | 8.0 | Romania | 7.1 |
Download the numbers in Excel
Download text file (csv format)
March 28, 2013
Data and charts: Annual trends charts
March 28, 2013
Bulgaria: Country outlook
FROM THE ECONOMIST INTELLIGENCE UNIT
POLITICAL STABILITY: Bulgaria has entered a period of political uncertainty after mass protests led to the resignation of the centre-right Citizens for European Development of Bulgaria (CEDB) government and the appointment of a caretaker administration, which will govern until pre-term parliamentary elections on May 12th. The prime minister, Boiko Borisov, submitted his resignation on February 20th, following several days of mass protests, some of which turned violent. The demonstrations were sparked by higher electricity bills, but quickly transformed into generalised protests against the government, much like those in Romania a year earlier. There, too, protests sparked by a specific issue (health service reforms) became the focus for broader anti-government protests over austerity and corruption, resulting in the collapse of the centre-right government. However, unlike in Romania, where a ready-made centre-left coalition was ready to step in and form an interim government (pending scheduled elections six months later), none of the parliamentary parties in Bulgaria, including the Bulgarian Socialist Party (BSP), was prepared to form a government. This has forced the holding of early parliamentary elections (the scheduled poll was due in July 2013). The outcome of the election is uncertain and a prolonged period of political bargaining may follow, possibly resulting in the formation of an unstable coalition.
ELECTION WATCH: Recent events have conspired to move the date of the next general election, which had been scheduled for July 7th 2013, and a pre-term poll will be held on May 12th.
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS: The EU will continue to monitor Bulgaria closely and may impose penalties if the country fails to meet its commitments. The latest report by the European Commission, published in July 2012, pointed to continuing shortcomings, including a lack of convictions in cases of organised crime, and concern about the management of the judiciary. To give Bulgaria more time to make progress in these areas, the Commission said that instead of publishing regular six-monthly reports, the next report on Bulgaria will not be issued until the end of 2013. Although the country's problems are widespread and entrenched, The Economist Intelligence Unit expects some progress in 2013-17, including an improvement in the absorption of EU funds. Bulgaria has met the technical requirements for joining the Schengen area, but political opposition within the EU means that entry will be delayed until mid-2013 at the earliest.
POLICY TRENDS: Pending the May 12th elections the caretaker administration will have to deal with urgent matters such as overseeing several large infrastructure projects, distributing EU cohesion funds for 2014-20 and managing the state finances. In practice, the interim government is unlikely to be office long enough to leave an imprint on policy. However, the coalition government that comes to power after the May 12th general election, whatever its political make-up, is likely to preside over a change of policy emphasis, if not a complete overhaul. It is likely to put more emphasis on tackling unemployment and promoting growth, without jeopardising the country's prized fiscal stability. The government is unlikely to pursue nationalisation, as demanded by some protesters, but will focus on increasing competition and improving the business environment to attract investors.
ECONOMIC GROWTH: Recovery from the recession of 2009 has been slow, with real GDP growth averaging 1% per year in 2010-12. In 2012 growth slowed to 0.8% year on year, from 1.9% in 2011, as faltering economic activity in the euro zone, Bulgaria's main trade partner, caused export performance to weaken. With the outlook for the euro zone remaining gloomy, and a domestic political crisis compounding investor uncertainty, we forecast that growth will be modest in 2013, at 1.3% (previously 1.5%). We expect a gradual acceleration in growth rates during 2014-17--driven by private consumption, fixed investment and exports--with real GDP growth accelerating to an annual average of 3.3%, which is still well below pre-crisis rates of around 6%.
INFLATION: Average inflation slowed to 3% (according to national methodology) in 2012, from 4.2% in 2011, owing to a decline in international non-oil commodity prices and a weakening of the global economic recovery. Inflation was subdued in January-June 2012, at an average of 1.8% year on year. Although it rose to 4.1% in the second half of the year, driven by higher international food prices, we expect inflationary pressures to moderate in the coming months. However, tensions in the Middle East could lead to a spike in oil prices, which would be likely to push up inflation in Bulgaria.
EXCHANGE RATES: The currency board arrangement still retains strong political commitment, and it is expected to stay in place until euro adoption (which is not expected in the forecast period), with the lev fixed to the euro at Lv1.95583:EUR1. Although the real effective exchange rate (REER) of the lev appreciated significantly in the pre-crisis years, it has depreciated since 2011, allaying concerns about economic competitiveness. The euro zone debt crisis has diminished the allure of joining the euro, and the government has become more circumspect about applying for entry into the EU's exchange-rate mechanism (ERM2), saying that it will not do so until the crisis is resolved.
EXTERNAL SECTOR: The current-account surplus in 2011, of 0.9% of GDP--the first surplus since 1997--reflected strong export performance, supported by higher commodity prices. We estimate that the current account slipped back into a small deficit in 2012, with export performance weakening more markedly than import performance as the government pressed on with infrastructure projects ahead of the 2013 election. We forecast that relatively strong export growth will partly offset the increased demand for imports as economic growth accelerates in 2013-17, and that during this period the current-account deficit will average the equivalent of 3.3% of GDP per year.
March 28, 2013
Country forecast overview: Highlights
March 28, 2013
Total area
111,002 sq km, of which 28% is arable land and 33% forest
Population
7.61m (December 2008)
Main cities
Population in '000 (December 2007) (a):
Sofia (capital): 1,241
Plovdiv: 705
Varna: 460
Burgas: 420
Stara Zagora: 356
Blagoevgrad: 329
Pleven: 298
Pazardzhik: 294
(a) Population figures relate to planning districts (oblasts) rather than cities.
Climate
Continental
Weather in Sofia (altitude 550 metres)
Hottest month, July, average temperature 21°C; coldest month, January, average temperature -2.3°C; driest month, April, 18 mm average rainfall; wettest month, June, 91 mm average rainfall
Language
Bulgarian
Weights and measures
Metric system
Currency
Lev (Lv) = 100 stotinki; the plural of lev is leva
Time
Two hours ahead of GMT in winter; three hours ahead in summer
Fiscal year
Calendar year
Public holidays
January 1st (New Year), March 3rd (Liberation Day), April 16th (Easter Monday), May 1st (Labour Day), May 6th (St George's Day), May 24th (Saints Cyril and Methodius), September 6th (Unification Day), September 22nd (Independence Day), November 1st (National Revival Day), December 24th-26th (Christmas)
January 07, 2013